Select Page

The Joke – Did you hear the one about …..

Jul 2, 2025 | Articles, CAOSYS News, Latest News

….. is the typical way to start any really good joke, however the stories I am about to tell you here were no joke for the people involved, neither for the victims or, ultimately, the perpetrators. So, sit back, and let me take you through a few horror stories you might, or might not, have heard before and some that might just make you smile at the irony (obviously, the company names and those of individuals are only mentioned if they are commonly found in the public domain).

For instance, did you hear the one about Hampshire’s leading builders’ merchant, Elliotts. In business since 1842, it was in 2019 their accountant was jailed for five years after stealing more than £400,000 over seven years to fund a gambling addiction. Kathleen Weir (aka Griffin), the deputy head management accountant at the firm, spent £1.2m on online sports betting! She made transactions from the firm, using nine different bank accounts in her two surnames to stash the stolen cash and then buried the transactions so that her bosses wouldn’t see them. Sadly, procedures to prevent fraud “were not strictly adhered to” by other employees at the firm. Whoops, bet they’ve fixed that now, and I bet it cost a fraction of the £400k they lost.

And then there was the massive Italian giant Parmalat, where things went very sour for the milk and UHT producer. It all started to ‘go off’ when the company went public, with the company’s fiscal shortfalls being deeply hidden by an elaborate scheme of false financial statements and billings. The bogus billings between chains of holding companies would make it seem the company had assets and income that didn’t really exist. This kicked off a cycle whereby increasing losses were kept secret and covered up with public bond offerings which were held to raise more cash. Things finally boiled over when it was revealed that a €4 billion bank account held by a Cayman Islands unit did not exist. During further investigation, prosecutors discovered a gargantuan €14+ billion deficit in their accounts which made Parmalat one of the largest financial frauds in history. The CEO was sentenced to 18 years in jail for fraudulent bankruptcy and criminal conspiracy, and in December 2003, the company folded! If only they had put an internal controls framework in place!

And then the one in 2014 about that lovely accountant lady running the finance department at Reed (the recruitment consultants), you know the one with the disabled daughter. Sadly, turns out, not so lovely and not so much a qualified accountant. Seems Karen Carberry, not only forged a certificate to get her job as finance director but she stole more than £300,000 to indulge her ‘love of shopping’ for designer shoes and handbags. She got away with the fraud for more than three years before one of her junior staff became suspicious at errors in the accounts. Carberry used her control over the Maltese accounts to hide bogus payments made into her credit card and was able to ‘blag’ her way through audits. Ummm, maybe the auditors should have hired someone to dig a little deeper into risk management!

And for a little more continental flair, the one about the management’s retirement fund. In was back in 2013 when Dutch infrastructure group Imtech NV was at the centre of fraud allegations. These came to light after an internal investigation revealed fraud had cost the company hundreds of millions of euros. It was alleged that senior executives of Imtech’s German division ordered managers to revise their financial statements upwards, and made €30m in unjustifiable payments to a company it refers to as “X Group”, which employed former managers from Imtech.

Between the fraud first coming to light in February 2013 and June 2013, its shares fell by 60%. In all the company lost a value of €1 billion on the stock market and June 2013 the company confessed that internal controls had not worked. Sadly, having lost that much value, the company could not get the backing from bankers to save itself and on the 13th of August 2015, the company was made bankrupt, and everyone lost their jobs.

And these stories don’t touch the ones we all HAVE heard about, the WorldCom and Enron scandals that were the catalyst for SOX or the story of Rita Crundwell, turned into a movie shown on Netflix (https://www.allthequeenshorsesfilm.com/) who managed to steal $53m from the city of Dixon in Illinois, claimed to be the USA’s largest municipal fraud. Yes, that is $37k per day for 20+ years!

So maybe the joke is that this kind of thing can happen to company’s big AND small, with any damage to a company’s reputation having a horrible knock-on effect to its share price or its business in general which, as we have seen above, can turn out to be disastrous. But then the loss is never just financial, it’s not just the families of those people who get caught and then waste years in jail, but other employees who might well lose their jobs when a company goes under.

In almost EVERY instance of corporate financial fraud, it is the complete lack or weakness of internal or external (auditors) controls that normally provide the safeguard, the checksum, the oversight, that are to blame. In simple terms, yes, it costs money and time to make sure they are effective and work, but the alternative can cost significantly more, and not just in monetary terms.

So don’t be fooled or lulled into a false sense of security. That doting mother or that gentle old man can sometimes turn out to be the fraudster and embezzler. If you don’t already have the best risk management and internal control framework in place, then you still have time to put things right before we’re telling a story about you.

Related Posts

CAOSYS Solutions on Oracle Marketplace

CAOSYS Solutions Now Available on Oracle Marketplace 7th October 2026 CAOSYS has announced that its integrated governance, risk, compliance and reporting solutions for Oracle E-Business Suite are now listed on Oracle Marketplace. The listings mark another step in...

read more

“Supported” Isn’t the Same as Invested In

"Supported" Isn't the Same as Invested In Part 2 of a three-part series on staying with Oracle E-Business Suite. Part 1 made the case that staying is a legitimate strategy rather than a delay. You ask a vendor when a particular capability is coming, and the answer is...

read more

Happy Customers

Enterprise GRC And Productivity Solutions That Keep Your Oracle Enterprise Applications Secure

Discover how CAOSYS solutions for Oracle EBS and Oracle ERP Cloud can enhance your internal controls and improve productivity.